Too Cool for School Milk Tint in Milky Lavender

This is, what, the third purple lip color I’ve reviewed in the last month? Oh, well.

I don’t think it’s possible to be a lipstick-loving k-pop fan without developing a curiosity about Korean lip tints. I’d had my eye out for a tint since last year, but most of the tints available in the US seemed to come in very bright colors (orange and pink being the most popular) and watery, ultra-staining formulas that I knew would dry the hell out of my lips. By the time I visited oo35mm, a deceptively tiny store in New York’s Chinatown with an impressive selection of Asian (mostly Korean and Japanese) beauty products, I’d pretty much given up on finding a relatively non-drying lip tint in my preferred purply color family. I was actually at oo35mm for skincare: I wanted a Salux exfoliating body washcloth, which I’d read about in this Into the Gloss post (see, I do like ITG sometimes), as well as some sheet masks from brands I hadn’t yet tried. But when I saw the Too Cool for School display, with its array of pastel lip tints in cardboard milk cartons holy shit, it was all over for me.

Too Cool for School’s Milk Tints come in four colorsMilky Lavender, Milky Orange, Milky Pink, and Milky Red—and retail for $7.99, at least at oo35mm. While in the store, I swatched Milky Lavender (second from right below) next to some other, more conventional lip tints. The two on the left are from Peripera, the one between those two and Milky Lavender is probably Milky Orange, and I think the one on the far right is also Peripera:

Here they are perhaps an hour after I made the swatches. As you can see, Milky Lavender and Milky Orange (?) are much less pigmented than the others, but my skin also looks less dry beneath them. The Peripera tints are very bold, but they’re really highlighting the texture of my skin. That seems to be the inevitable tradeoff with lip tints.

I won’t lie, I bought Milky Lavender mainly for the packaging. Not only does the cardboard box look like a milk carton, but the tint itself has a milk bottle on it:

I love how sturdy the bottle is: it’s made of very thick plastic, and the top screws on securely. The applicator is a stubby little doefoot:

If anyone reading this knows Korean and can tell me what the back of the bottle says, that would be awesome! I can read some Hangul but can only sound out the characters…

This won’t make me sound like a very responsible consumer, but I’ll say it anyway: I was so delighted with the packaging that I wouldn’t have minded much if the lip tint itself had turned out to be mediocre. As it happens, though, I’m very pleased with Milky Lavender. It’s a light pinky purple in the radiant-orchid family, and I don’t know about you, but I’m not over Pantone’s 2014 color yet. Witness the deck chairs on which I’m typing this very post:

I do have a few similar lip colors to Milky Lavender, but in different formulas. L-R: Maybelline Lilac Flush, Milky Lavender, NYX Butter Gloss in Raspberry Tart, Maybelline Brazen Berry:

Milky Lavender goes on quite sheer, but you can see it darken before your eyes, like watching a Polaroid develop. After one coat, it’s a light purply pink that blends well with my natural coolish-toned lip color; after three coats (as I prefer to wear it), it’s a medium pinky lilac. Like the Glossier Generation G lipsticks I reviewed in March and April, Milky Lavender is never going to be opaque, and the texture of your lips will show through no matter how much product you pile on. That’s just in the nature of lip tints. Milky Lavender is unusual in one respect, though: it has a slight sheen when first applied, though that disappears within an hour or so, fading to the standard matte lip-tint finish. The tint has a subtle, sweet floral scent that reminds me of jasmine tea; I find it very pleasant, but if you don’t like scented lip products, this might be one to avoid.

Here are my bare lips for comparison—it’s a rare day when my lips aren’t peeling, flaking, or bleeding, so I’m glad I seized the opportunity to get a photo back on May 1:

And here we have one, two, and three coats of Milky Lavender, all freshly applied:

Milky Lavender hangs on for a long time, through eating, drinking, and even a strenuous (read: extremely sweaty) hourlong workout. It does fade first from the center of my lips, so I find myself reapplying it to that area every few hours. As it fades, it becomes brighter and pinker (something I’ve observed with my Revlon Balm Stain in Crush as well). I don’t find Milky Lavender particularly drying—no more so, at least, than any other staining or matte product. It’s easy to apply lip balm over the color, as well.

Here it is on my face—I generally pair it with boring understated makeup for my low-maintenance days. The sheen has faded a bit here:

Here I’ve done a blue-gray eye with, if you can believe it, four different shadows: Urban Decay Skimp (light beige) all over the lid and Frisk (light taupe) in the crease; a deep grayish teal from my theBalm custom palette layered over Skimp; and…uh, I forget what I used for liner, sorry. It’s funny, I was thinking of Milky Lavender as a soft foil for a bolder eye look, but the combination of blue shadow and lavender lips came out looking distressingly ’80s. Pardon the wet hair.

And a closeup of the eyes:

Though I usually stick to my reliable neutral eyeshadows, I’ve been trying to experiment more with color and blending and layering. I don’t have a huge eyeshadow collection, but it’s large enough that I know I can do a lot more than I’m currently doing!

By the way, I’m leaving for the UK in two days, and it seems unlikely that I’ll get around to reviewing my nude glosses or pink lip samples before then. Oh well, two out of four isn’t bad (I mean, it’s an F, but whatever). Let me know if anything exciting has come out in the world of British/European beauty since I visited last year!


16 thoughts on “Too Cool for School Milk Tint in Milky Lavender

  1. The colour looks great! I'm glad it worked out for you. I only very very recently discovered the quirky nerdiness that is Too Cool For School – Have you seen their dinosaur mascara and shit? And Rodin inspired contour powder and stuff? AWESOME. (I don't have anything from them yet tho.)For bolder eye looks, maybe you could amp up the saturation and vibrancy a little instead of blending it out. I know it's somewhat out of your comfort zone, but no harm trying right? 😛 Maybe it'll even turn out as crazy-notcrazy and totally befitting your skin tone like Stone Fox did. WRT British beauty – I've been lemming hard over Newtrals vs Neutrals from Makeup Revolution *_* Kiko's new lipstick range has AMAZINGLY luxe packaging too, and I've always liked their formulas. Maybe you could check those out!


  2. Yesss, Too Cool's packaging is adorable. I'm currently lusting after one of their Dinoplatz liquid eyeshadows but I'll wait and see if I both want AND need it.I have the lip tint in Milky Red and I love it despite being misnamed. It's pink, not red. But it's a flattering pink on me so hey!Anyway, something weird happens after a few hours of applying Milky Red. The color nearly disappears from my upper lip so it looks like I only applied color to my bottom lip. I mean, reapplying is not a problem but it does make me a wee bit self-conscious when talking to others. I was wondering if anyone else has the same problem.


  3. I have to agree with Renee – too pink for me! Where is the sheer, blue-toned, pale purple lip color?? I would throw down for that any day of the week. I really love that blue-grey eye look. I mostly wear blue eyes with neutral-warm (not nude, but in the MLBB family) lips, as blue seems to steer any cool lip color into 80s territory.


  4. Yessss, I've seen the dinosaur mascara! I don't buy non-drugstore mascara (doesn't seem worth it when I have to get rid of it in a few months), but I'll have to check out their other stuff, some of which is now sold at Sephora. I took your advice and am wearing ColourPop Shop today, with a bit of black shadow as liner! I did blend it out a bit, but I'd like to get more comfortable with vibrant eye looks. And thanks for the tips! The only Kiko products I've tried are eyeshadows, but I've been impressed with those, so I'll check out the new lipsticks if I make it to the Kiko store in London.


  5. Weird! The product disappears mostly from my bottom lip, but come to think of it, a little bit wears off my top lip as well. It's definitely not the longest-wearing lip tint out there. I'd like to try a more traditional lip tint and see how that compares.


  6. You're right, it's definitely the cool-toned lip that's pulling the eye look into '80s land. I was pleased with the blue-gray combo, but next time I'll try it with a sheer warm-toned lip color like Glossier Cake.


  7. I still miss Radiant Orchid! A colour of the year has not spoken to me so strongly since. Milky Lavender is a great colour. Maybe we can just elect to bring back Radiant Orchid one lip colour at a time…And where I went to school a 2/4 would actually be the minimum you need to pass, so maybe that will make you feel better! D- instead of an F?


  8. I actually loved Marsala as well, but 2016's colors of the year are a total fail for me. So few people look good in them. And if Pantone is trying to unsettle gender norms or whatever, why choose two colors that are traditionally used to reinforce the gender binary and, like, not DO anything with them? Why not combine them into a light purple and make that the color of the year? It just seems like a cheap, lazy attempt to piggyback on actual social progress. I have a lot of feelings about Pantone, apparently…By the way, your hair looks very Radiant Orchid in your avatar photo!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s